Tuesday, February 14, 2017

REVIEWS Omkar Alta Monte

Overview

Before I begin this review let me tell you this is perhaps the best marketed redevelopment project ever… and this makes this review VERY interesting. I remember meeting a friend who suggested this property to me at 7000 psf. almost 4 years back. I heard Omkar and I was like.. “you know this is a 10 year old developer, I don’t know if he will deliver”. Fast forward to the present: Omkar Alta Monte stands out and competes with the best brands in the market. Lets look at the reason as to why this is happening!
According to a Mid Day report in Feb 2010 “while rules state that the builder has to return 25 per cent of a cemetery plot that goes into redevelopment, the Slum Rehabilitation Authority’s FSI calculation let Omkar Realtors give only 8 per cent in a Malad project”

The project in question is Omkar Alta Monte, being developed by Omkar Realtors. The builder had acquired a plot of 46,993 sq. metres for his project, which included the rehabilitation of 15,000 slums built on it. A part of the land was a Hindu cemetery admeasuring 5,987.60 square metres.
According to Appendix 4 of the Development Control Rules 33 (10), a developer who utilises cemetery land for redevelopment is supposed to return 25 per cent of the original plot area after the project. This means for the above plot, Omkar Realtors had to give back 1,496.90 square metres to the SRA.
Omkar it seems wriggled out of this controversy and now as they say the rest is history.
A brilliant marketing campaign changed the perception about the product. Its not as if dog creches, large swimming pools and luxurious living spaces were unheard of, its just the way in which the entire proposition was presented. Add to that Omkar capitalized on L&T’s construction forte and used that advantage to the maximum.

Quick Fact Check:
  • The project consists of 4 towers with a ground + 7 podiums and an 8th floor amenity level. The towers are 45 to 55 floors plus.
  • An earthquake resistant RCC construction with a flat slab structure.
  • A well designed external facade by International architects.
  • Automated Parking Card reader for security and exclusive access
  • Looks good on paper – Lets see if this is actually validated.

Location Check:

Malad is a suburb, 34 km north of Mumbai its distant on paper however its fast becoming an IT HUB with many organizations opening their facilities. A quick check on the location and you will realize its convenient and comfortable but not perfect. The tower is imposing and visible from a distance even in its current under construction mode. Located on the western express highway these residences overlooking the Sanjay Gandhi National Park, are a 5 minute drive from Oberoi Mall and only 30 minutes away from the airport (non peak hours) . (Disclaimer: Apartments facing the east get a very bad view.)
There are at least 5 malls and the largest of them is Infinity Mall in a 5 km radius.
With a walkscore of 88 most of your needs are sorted. Oberoi Mall is your answer to all your questions.

The minuses are that a few grocery stores would have been an advantage and add to that its located towards KURAR village which is a slum zone which invites miscreants.


The philosophy of the master plan is minimum area maximum amenities. Since the plot area is small the developer has opted for multiple levels for recreational activity, 7 levels of parking, 5 acres of split landscaped area, and I should give him credit for the same. Since the intention is good. 
Construction for me is destined to be precise and immaculate since the same is being handled by L & T. They are using Mivan technology so this section is pretty sorted.
On the design bit, I find everything to be force fitted. These are not your regular natural floor plans and designs. The layout is unconventional. Bedroom sizes seem to be a little cramped. (second bedrrom100 sq.ft….. well someone said this is a luxury development?)
Yes the apartments come with decks which is a good thing but overall the plans should have been better.

On the amenities bit: Move over your regular gardens, swimming pools, play areas…sky lounges, infinity pool and qua gym, elevated jogging track are aspirational features which todays urban youth would happily lap up. Over and above the project has a tennis court, gym, basket ball court. SO that is pretty fair. Agglomerated marble in living - dinning room and kitchen, CP fittings Jaquar "Continental" or equivalent should give your house a thrusting look and feel. Each apartment has the provision to keep outdoor A.C. Units which is good additionally the product comes with video Door Phone Provided
internet Wi-fi Connectivity, ready to use home automation, parking Card reader with proximity sensor.
This is a feature heavy product: Thumbs up on this section.

What do we like

Location of the Project
Decks
L&T Construction

What we dont like

This project is marketed as a luxury project but I find the space is missing (the room size’s for 2 and 3 bhk are very small. The room sizes and utility areas are cramped
SRA Development ??

Final verdict

This is one of the best Slum rehabilitation product in the Mumbai market. If you want an address to flash, you don’t travel by train and aspire to live a luxury lifestyle this is your project; It works. As long as the pricing differential between this product and Kalpataru Radiance/ Ekta Tripolis/ Lodha Fiorenza is 30 %. If not go for the latter.

Mayfair Hillcrest Review

Overview

Our ever-demanding market has forced developers to pack every segment to the hilt. Earlier, there would be a luxury segment, followed by a premium segment, and then an affordable segment. Not anymore. Now, there’s a compact luxury segment, then a compact premium segment, and a super compact affordable segment. As our demands continue to grow, as do our choices.
Mayfair in this attempt to create something new introduced the cross ‘SRA – Premium - Luxe’ category. It’s an affordable slum rehab project which has been marketed as a luxury product. Sounds complicated right? So quickly coming to the product per say:
On the looks front, the frontage looks stunning, biggest highlight of the Hillcrest is fact that the project is located on a hill where the first habitable floor is 4 levels above the ground. Top it up with a 30,000 sq. ft. Podium, Landscaped Gardens, Swimming Pool, Gymnasium designed by Mark Mahan of Singapore and it seems like a winner. But hold on!!
The developer has been attempting to launch this project since 2010, however he was facing multiple issues with regards to approvals since part of the land belongs to the government for whom the developer was supposed to construct low-cost housing and hand it over to MHADA. The process took time and the project got delayed. In fact if you have a look at the master plan it has 1 Room kitchen and other 2 BHK apartments for sale on the same floor.

Location

In terms of connectivity and social infrastructure the location as such is extremely good: R City mall round the corner makes the shopping and entertainment a convenient. A 5 minute drive takes you to Hiranandani Powai where you have the best of schools, hospitals and restaurants. Godrej which is spread across 500 acres has decided to lease out land is now transforming into an IT and Pharma hub. VIkhroli as a destination now has it all. The location is self-sufficient however you will need a car for easy commute. A couple of negatives, there are slums around the project which area a major deterrent also currently the approach road is a virtual auto and taxi parking lot which can be a nuisance.

Plans

The developer has tried his best to fit in maximum amenities in the project and full marks to him for the same given the constraints & size of the plot. Maximum amenities are slotted on the podium and the zone has been kept vehicle free. Not ideal but manageable. 
Coming to the floor plans: Let me sum it up in one line, they are super compact. A 2 BHK set up in a carpet of 675 sq. ft. is not ideal. Bathrooms of size 6 ft. x 4 ft. and living room of size 15 ft. x 10 ft. is certainly not adequate for a young family. In case of the 1 BHK the bedroom is of approx. 100 sqft. and you feel pressed for space. The living space leaves a lot to be desired.

What do we like


  • Good connectivity
  • Good social infrastructure
  • Will be easy to rent out
  • Great views

What we dont like

  • Floor plan
  • Water supply issues
  • Slums around the plot

Final verdict

Well to its credit it’s an excellent location and a beautiful view of the Vashi creek and Godrej Greens. This is one of the rare projects that I have come across where rates are being quoted based on carpet area. This is one of the rare projects that I have come across where construction schedule and delivery timelines are mentioned in newspapers and websites. This is one of the rare projects that I have come across where the approved documents are made available online.
But all said and done its more of an investor product, less of an end use product.

Marathon NexTown Review

Overview

Dombivali as a location has seen huge appreciation over the last couple years. The reason for this phenomenon is the landmark project by Lodha group in this suburban area. It has changed the future potential as well as the profile of the area. Marathon Nextown is a project by marathon group in Dombivali offering 1 and 2 bedroom apartments to prospective home buyers. This new project by Marathon will be located near Shil Phata in Dombivli East. Let’s have quick fat check about the project

Quick Fact Check

Marathon Nextown is a part of the 90 acre township which is located 5 Kms from Dombivli Station & 4 km from the Diva Station.
  • Spacious 1 & 2 BHK apartments
  • 14 acres project
  • Total floors: 18
  • World class modern amenities
  • Vaastu Compliant
  • Piped-gas
  • Swimming Pool
  • Park
  • Security Personnel
  • Maintenance Staff
  • Bank Attached Property
  • Fitness Centre / GYM
  • Club house / Community Center
  • Water softening plant
  • Shopping Centre
  • Waste Disposal
  • Rain Water Harvesting
  • Feng Shui / Vaastu Compliant
  • Intercom Facility
  • Water purifier
  • Lift(s)
  • Reserved Parking
  • Society/ Building Features
  • Water Storage
  • Internet/wi-fi connectivity
  • Visitor Parking 

Location

The project is located very close to Kalyan Shil road. Although, it is quite far from the stations on the central line, the road connectivity is relatively better. It's very close to Shilphata junction and Lodha group’s upcoming township of Palava. With the area set to see infrastructure developments in future along with improved connectivity, this location is bound to see good appreciation also. In fact, the resident staying at Casa Bella and Casa Rio have seen decent rentals for ready possession properties as well. There is a lot of interest from people working in areas like Mhape to buy in Dombivali.

Plans

The master plan currently available online for the project shoes a lot of clutter with relatively less open spaces. In addition, the shape of the plot is also not regular. We would have preferred much more open spaces since marathon group is known for delivering value residences with top of the line amenities 
  
In 1 bedroom apartments, you can see that the kitchen is right next to the entrance of the apartment which does not bode well for the privacy of the residents. Having two toilets in a 1 bedroom apartment is a good call although the dining area looks a bit cramped for our taste. The two bedroom apartments also look efficiently designed with the only problem being the kitchen right next to the entrance.

What do we like

  • Brand name and delivery capability
  • Future infrastructure potential
  • Appreciation potential of the location and investment opportunity

What we dont like

  • Approach road
  • Relatively cluttered master-plan and relatively less open spaces

Final verdict

The overall project plan is quite nice and if you are looking for solid investment option, Nextown offers a good potential. It is also available at a small discount to Palava which can be a consideration as well. However, the scale of the project is nowhere comparable to Palava so you might consider that as well before taking a final call.

Rajesh Lifespaces White City Review

Overview

Whem Rajesh Lifespace launched White city, they took up the biggest hoarding in Mumbai to advertise the launch Needless to say, the project received sufficient attention from the target group.  At the same time with the decent brand name that Rajesh commands in the market, the project looked like a sure shot winner. Located in Kandivali east, white city boasts of some of the best amenities available in suburban region. Let's do quick fact check of the project
Quick Fact Check
  • Split AC in living room and bedrooms
  • Italian marble flooring in living & dining room
  • Anodized aluminium windows
  • Granite kitchen service platforms along with water purifier
  • Anti-skid marble/vitrified tiles in bathrooms
  • Premium sanitary fittings in all bathrooms with vanity counters
  • Segregation of wet and dry areas
  • Wi-Fi enabled lobbies
  • Well-equipped gymnasium
  • Exquisite cabana
  • Dedicated jogging track
  • Lavish swimming pool
  • Contemporary deck with lounge seating
  • Superior clubhouse
  • Badminton
  • Squash
  • Table tennis
  • Gymnasium
  • Games room
Location

White city is located in Kandivali east very close to the national park. The location will ensure that the project gets very good views and is close to nature. Lokandwala’s project is also located very close to it. There is no problem of social infrastructure as well. The only issue is that the distance from western express highway is relative more. At the same time, it's quite far suburban rail network. In addition, the project is very close slums as well.
Plans
If we look at the project layout we can see project buildings laid out in a curvature with the clubhouse in the middle. The rest of the amenities are relatively well spaced out. With the entrance of the project on Akruili Road, the buildings on east side of the plot will be closer to the national park. The layout looks well- spaced out with sufficient spacing between the buildings.

Floor Plans

White city offers the whole gamut of 1, 2 and 3 bedroom apartments
If we look at the typical floor plan of 1 bedroom apartment, we can see that the entrance is in 3 and half feed wide lobby. The bedroom is a bit smaller to our liking. Although, the size of kitchen and toilets are sufficient and second toilet is a plus, living and dying areas are quite small



Coming to the 2 BHK plan, although the master bedroom is sufficient the second bedroom size is small again. The same issue which is there with one bedroom floor plan that is of kitchen right next to the entrance which will ensure lack of privacy for residents exists here too. 



The three bedroom plan is less efficient as compared to the previous two with good amount of space wasted in entrance lobby. Again, the master bedroom size is sufficient but is seriously lacking in others. Overall, White city boasts of decent floor plans which could have been more efficient and spacious.

What do we like


  • Location
  • Brand name of Rajesh Life spaces
  • Decent masterplan
  • Social Infrastructure around the project

What we dont like


  • Slums around the project
  • Distance from WEH and Railway Stations
  • Relatively small carpet areas

Final verdict

It is a decent project from a reputed developer and can surely be considered as an option if you are more focused on amenities and can do away with relatively smaller bedrooms in the apartments. 

Hiranandani Thane: Rodas Enclave Review

Overview

Rodas Enclave is not just another attempt by Hiranandani to give Thane with one more residential township. In fact, it is the harbinger of a new era of living and lifestyle in Thane.Rodas Enclave will give the concept of spacious living a formidable shape and new dimension. While all the towers would be built on podium garden, the apartments won’t just be smarter in looks but larger in size too. The Group is known for its projects of Hiranandani Gardens, Powai, Hiranandani Meadows, Thane, Hiranandani Estate, Thane, Hiranandani Business Park Powai & Thane.
QUICK FACT CHECK
It has 18 majestic buildings of 18, 24, and 28 floors, lavish 2, 3, 4 and 5 BHK apartments, a floating clubhouse, a magnificent green zone, numerous avenues of recreation and entertainment all of these perched on an elevated podium. Add to this the amenities offered by an integrated township and it becomes a good option.

Location

Patlipada was the village located on Ghodbunder Road, Maharashtra state in India. It is now a part of Thane city. Now this small village has grown into a most promising place with major Residential Complex and Official Residence of Thane Municipal Commissioner located in this area. Patlipada is Located on the Ghodbunder Road which is 6 – 7 km away from the Thane Railway Station. As Patlipada was Village mostly land was covered with agriculture fields and quite near to the National Park. Now this has changed the village is transformed into a town and it can be said that it is in competition with the main Thane City itself. The project boasts of excellent social infrastructure in forms of schools, malls and shopping centres.
This location has a Walk Score of 62 out of 100. This location is Somewhat Walkable so some errands can be accomplished on foot. Nearby parks include Nisarg Garden, Nisarg Garden and Hiranandani Park. Nearby schools include Arun Muchhala Inst Of Hotel Management And Catering Tech, Dr. Ashok B. Karnik and New Horizon Scholars School & Neo Kids.The closest grocery stores are Bhankharia Tea Stationery & General Stores, Hypercity and Vagheshwari Kirana Store. Nearby coffee shops include Cafe Coffee Day - Hypercity, Ghodbunder Road, Pet Puja and L.K. Caife & Foods. Nearby restaurants include Dominos, Dominos Pizza and Kailash Dairy Farm & Restaurant.

Plans

The layout though not an even shape is still planned to utmost perfection. Most of the apartments will get views of the garden and the clubhouse (a separate clubhouse for exclusive for Rodas Enclave residents). In terms of external amenities the product has it all The only hitch is there are almost 18 towers in the plot. A little over stuffed?  Privacy in some apartments might be compromised.

There are 18 different set of floor plans and it will be difficult to evaluate them all, so we have randomly picked up a typical floor plan in Bankston; lets see what the product has to offer.Y shaped tower, a big advantage since there are no common walls and the apartment gets cross ventilation and natural sunlight. There are 2 variants of 3 BHKs.Flat 1 & 2: The apartment has a foyer which opens up into the living room (ensuring privacy in the apartment). A spacious 21 * 12 living dining space with an attached deck ensures luxury! Bedrooms sizes of 15 * 11, 13 * 11 & 12 * 11 ensure you have enough room in your living space. Flat 3: These apartments come with similar bedroom sizes. The only difference is that you enter into a grand living dining space which further extends to the deck area.Overall these are well planned efficient apartments.

What do we like

Almost everything

What we dont like

Density
Godhbunder is growing yet it’s a little far away from the city - Poor connectivity by public transport is a major concern

Final verdict

If you are an end user this project is a winner, the range of choice begins from 2 BHK to 5 BHK, all bigger by measure than the standard norm. There are 18 towers in the project. The project has excellent location and boasts of top of the line amenities that come with an integrated township. Although, it is being sold at a premium to the market, it comes with the concept and the brand name of Hiranandani. Buyers should look at individual floor plans before their final decision and location of individual towers in the overall complex. If you are investor with a horizon of 5 to 8 years - Look at options closer to Balkum & Majiwada, kalpataru and Lodha are coming up with township products here